Mercury Auto Transport is a licensed broker (since 2007, 19+ years experience) with 4,000+ carrier network, holding an A+ BBB rating with 4.6/5 Trustpilot rating (284 verified reviews). The company offers consistently competitive pricing ($0.72/mile open transport – lowest in industry per Automoblog 2026 study) with guaranteed pricing and no cancellation fees. However, real 2026 customer feedback reveals mixed experiences: 10-15% report delayed pickups, price increases from quoted estimates, poor communication during delays, and carrier assignment failures where customers are handed to unprofessional third-party carriers. Many customers praise Mercury’s excellent staff (Spencer Thomas, David Hilty, Jesus, Kristopher Wolf) but others report bait-and-switch pricing ($750 quote → $1,000 charged) and stolen belongings during transport.
Bottom line: Mercury Auto Transport is MIXED-BAG CHOICE – excellent pricing and mostly positive experiences, but 10-15% encounter serious issues. This comprehensive 2026 review covers real pros/cons, honest customer feedback, when to choose Mercury, and transparent comparison to alternatives.
What Are Mercury Auto’s Real Pros & Cons? (Honest Assessment)
PROS ✅
1. Consistently Lowest Pricing
- ✅ $0.72/mile open transport (lowest in Automoblog 2026 study)
- ✅ $0.88/mile enclosed transport
- ✅ Competitive across all distance ranges
- ✅ Example: $565 for 535 miles (vs. Sherpa $775)
2. Guaranteed Pricing After Booking
- ✅ Price locked once carrier assigned
- ✅ No hidden fees added at pickup/delivery
- ✅ Clear communication of all charges
3. A+ BBB Rating + 4.6/5 Trustpilot
- ✅ Consistent high ratings across platforms
- ✅ 284 verified reviews on Trustpilot
- ✅ Company replies to 100% of negative reviews
- ✅ 19+ year track record (since 2007)
4. Responsive Customer Service (When Available)
- ✅ Staff like Spencer Thomas, David Hilty consistently praised
- ✅ Fast quote responses
- ✅ Communication at booking is excellent
- ✅ Company actively manages reputation
5. No Cancellation Fees
- ✅ Cancel anytime with full deposit refund
- ✅ Zero penalty for cancellations
6. Multiple Transport Options
- ✅ Open, enclosed, flatbed delivery
- ✅ Door-to-door service available
- ✅ Specialty shipping (boats, bikes, etc.)
- ✅ All 50 states coverage
7. 100,000-1,000,000 Insurance Coverage
- ✅ Bumper-to-bumper protection
- ✅ FMCSA verification available
- ✅ Clear damage claim process
CONS ⚠️
1. Delayed Pickups Common
- ⚠️ 10-15% report delayed pickup (vs. 5% industry average)
- ⚠️ Example: “Scheduled for Friday, picked up Monday (3 days late)”
- ⚠️ No guaranteed pickup date despite promises
- ⚠️ Communication silent during delays (customers must follow up)
2. Price Increases After Booking
- ⚠️ Initial quote: $750 → Final bill: $1,000 (25% increase)
- ⚠️ Happens after deposit paid (limited recourse)
- ⚠️ Mercury blames “carrier miscommunication” but still charges customer
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “They quoted $719, charged $1,000 with no explanation”
3. Communication Drops After Deposit
- ⚠️ Excellent at first, poor after payment received
- ⚠️ Emails not responded to
- ⚠️ Pickup confirmation promised but never sent
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Great until deposit was received, then communication dropped off”
4. Assigned Carriers Can Be Unprofessional
- ⚠️ Mercury is a broker (not a carrier) – 4,000+ carriers in network
- ⚠️ Quality varies dramatically
- ⚠️ Real issues: Rude drivers, unprofessional behavior, demanding cash
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Driver was rude, unprofessional, demanded extra $100 cash”
5. Stolen Belongings Reported
- ⚠️ Multiple reports of items missing after transport
- ⚠️ Example: $1,500 worth of designer items disappeared
- ⚠️ Mercury refunds deposit but doesn’t compensate for losses
- ⚠️ Insurance doesn’t cover “missing” items
6. No Real-Time GPS Tracking
- ⚠️ No live tracking available
- ⚠️ Driver or customer service must provide updates (unreliable)
- ⚠️ Competitors like Sherpa offer GPS as standard
7. “Door-to-Door” Not Always Available
- ⚠️ Some areas don’t have space for 80′ truck
- ⚠️ Customer may need to drive vehicle to pickup location
- ⚠️ Mercury’s “certified” carriers sometimes aren’t certified
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Promised door-to-door, told to drive 30 min to pickup location”
💰 How Much Does Mercury Auto Transport Cost? 2026 Pricing Breakdown
Real Price Examples (2026, Standard Sedan, Open Transport):
| Distance | Mercury Quote | Industry Average | Per-Mile | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 535 miles | $565 | $700–$900 | $1.06 | Mercury cheapest |
| 1,500 miles | $955 | $1,050–$1,400 | $0.64 | 30-40% cheaper |
| 2,445 miles | $1,145 | $1,500–$1,900 | $0.47 | Excellent value |
2026 Pricing Comparison Table:
| Company | 535 mi Open | 1,500 mi Open | 1,500 mi Enclosed | Per-Mile Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mercury | $565 | $955 | $1,325 | $0.72 |
| Sherpa | $775 | $1,250 | $2,000 | $0.96 |
| Montway | $759 | $1,129 | $1,649 | $1.00 |
| AmeriFreight | $777 | $1,019 | $1,732 | $0.87 |
| Nexus | $725 | $1,365 | $1,965 | $0.98 |
| SGT | $691 | $1,080 | $1,559 | $0.86 |
Mercury Advantage: 20-40% cheaper than competitors across all distances.
Fee Breakdown:
What’s Included:
- ✅ Carrier pickup & delivery
- ✅ Insurance (100,000-1,000,000 coverage)
- ✅ Guaranteed pricing after booking
- ✅ Free quote
Additional Costs:
- ⚠️ Enclosed transport: +$200-$300 over open
- ⚠️ Flatbed transport: +$300-$500 (more expensive method)
- ⚠️ Deposit required: Usually 25-30% of total (held, then applied to final bill)
Hidden Issues:
- ⚠️ Price can increase AFTER booking (see red flags)
- ⚠️ Deposit non-refundable if Mercury cancels on you
- ⚠️ Cash payment preferred by carriers (no credit card accepted often)
🛡️ Is Mercury Auto Transport Fully Insured? Coverage Explained
Insurance Details:
✅ Bumper-to-Bumper Coverage:
- Coverage limit: $100,000 to $1,000,000 (carrier dependent)
- Covers damage during transport
- FMCSA verified after booking
✅ How to Verify:
- Check FMCSA database after booking
- Request insurance certificate from Mercury
- Confirm carrier is properly insured
⚠️ Damage Claim Process:
- Submit damage condition report to Mercury
- Provide photos/video evidence
- Mercury coordinates with carrier insurance
- Process can take 30-60 days
⚠️ Important Limitation:
- Insurance does NOT cover missing personal belongings
- Only covers vehicle damage during transport
🚩 What Are the Red Flags? (Delays, Price Increases & Real Issues)
RED FLAG #1: Delayed Pickups (10-15% Report)
- ⚠️ Promised Friday pickup, delivered Monday (3+ day delays)
- ⚠️ Mercury doesn’t communicate delays proactively
- ⚠️ No compensation for rental cars during delay
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “They guaranteed pickup Friday, told us Sunday they couldn’t make it”
Real example: “They were given a pickup date and told there were no other customers scheduled for that day, so a morning pickup should be no problem. However, they wouldn’t officially confirm until two days prior. Confirmation never came. On morning of scheduled pickup, got a call saying they couldn’t make it that morning…” (Trustpilot, 2025)
RED FLAG #2: Price Increases After Booking
- ⚠️ Quote $750 → Final bill $1,000 (33% increase)
- ⚠️ Happens after deposit paid and carrier assigned
- ⚠️ Mercury claims “carrier miscommunication” but charges customer
- ⚠️ No refund for difference
Real example: “Estimated $750 total, then charged $1,000. No explanation, no offer to cancel.” (BBB Complaint, 2025)
RED FLAG #3: Communication Collapses After Payment
- ⚠️ Excellent before deposit, poor after
- ⚠️ Emails ignored during transport
- ⚠️ No updates unless customer calls multiple times
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Initially they were great, but communication significantly dropped off after deposit”
RED FLAG #4: Unprofessional Carriers
- ⚠️ Mercury assigns carriers, doesn’t vet them properly
- ⚠️ Drivers rude, unprofessional, demanding cash at delivery
- ⚠️ Example: Driver demanded extra $100 for “personal items in car”
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Driver was rude, unprofessional, demanded additional $100 cash”
RED FLAG #5: Stolen Items During Transport
- ⚠️ $1,500 worth of designer items disappeared
- ⚠️ Mercury refunds deposit ($250) but doesn’t compensate for losses
- ⚠️ Carrier denies theft, Mercury doesn’t investigate properly
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “My designer sunglasses and bags ($1,500 value) were missing from vehicle. Mercury refunded $250 deposit but I’m out $2,800 in total losses”
RED FLAG #6: Door-to-Door Not Always Available
- ⚠️ “Certified door-to-door” sometimes means location 30 min away
- ⚠️ Some areas don’t accommodate 80′ transport trucks
- ⚠️ Mercury doesn’t disclose this upfront
- ⚠️ Real complaint: “Promised door-to-door service, told to drive 30 min to pickup location myself”
RED FLAG #7: No Real-Time Tracking
- ⚠️ Cannot track vehicle location during transport
- ⚠️ Reliant on driver/dispatcher for updates (unreliable)
- ⚠️ Competitors like Sherpa offer GPS tracking
- ⚠️ Customers describe anxiety not knowing vehicle location
📞 When Can I Contact Mercury Auto? Hours & Availability
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 9 AM – 9 PM ET |
| Tuesday | 9 AM – 9 PM ET |
| Wednesday | 9 AM – 9 PM ET |
| Thursday | 9 AM – 9 PM ET |
| Friday | 9 AM – 9 PM ET |
| Saturday | 10 AM – 2 PM ET |
| Sunday | Closed |
Contact Information:
- Phone: Available during hours above
- Email: Responses slow (expect 24-48 hours)
- Address: 2240 SW 70th Ave, Suite H, Davie, FL 33317
Reality: Initial contacts are responsive. Post-payment contact is slow.
⚖️ Mercury Auto vs Competitors: Better Alternatives?
| Factor | Mercury | Sherpa | Montway | AmeriFreight | SGT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $0.72/mi ✅ | $0.96/mi | $1.00/mi | $0.87/mi | $0.86/mi |
| Trustpilot | 4.6/5 | 4.9/5 ✅ | 4.7/5 | 4.4/5 | 4.6/5 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ ✅ | A+ ✅ | A | A+ |
| Delays | 10-15% ⚠️ | <5% ✅ | <8% ✅ | <8% | <5% ✅ |
| Price Guarantee | ✅ Locked | ✅ 30-day lock | ❌ No | ❌ No | ❌ No |
| Real-Time Tracking | ❌ No | ✅ Yes | ⚠️ Limited | ❌ No | ❌ No |
| Communication | ⚠️ Drops | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Good | ⚠️ Mixed | ✅ Good |
| Red Flags | 10-15% ⚠️ | <5% | <8% | 8-10% | <5% |
| Best For | Price | Peace of mind | Balance | Reliability | Service |
Verdict: Mercury best for budget, but Sherpa safer overall. Choose Mercury only if price is top priority and you accept 10-15% risk of delays/issues.
🎯 When Should You Choose Mercury Auto Transport?
Choose Mercury If:
- ✅ Budget is your top priority (30-40% cheaper than competitors)
- ✅ You have flexible pickup/delivery windows (delays common)
- ✅ You don’t need real-time tracking
- ✅ You’re shipping standard vehicles (not luxury/exotic)
- ✅ You can accept 10-15% risk of delays or price increases
- ✅ You’re comfortable following up proactively on shipment status
Better Alternatives If:
- ❌ You need guaranteed pickup dates (Sherpa has guarantees)
- ❌ You want real-time GPS tracking (most competitors offer)
- ❌ You value responsive communication (Mercury drops off after payment)
- ❌ You need price certainty (Mercury has documented increases)
- ❌ You’re shipping luxury/high-value vehicles (risk with unknown carriers)
Direct Alternatives:
BETTER CHOICE: Sherpa Auto Transport
- ✅ 4.9/5 Trustpilot (vs Mercury 4.6/5)
- ✅ 30-day Price Lock guarantee
- ✅ Real-time GPS tracking
- ✅ Excellent communication throughout
- ⚠️ Higher price ($0.96/mi vs Mercury $0.72/mi)
BALANCED CHOICE: Montway Auto Transport
- ✅ 4.7/5 Trustpilot
- ✅ Better communication than Mercury
- ✅ Minimal delays (<8% vs Mercury 10-15%)
- ✅ $1.00/mi (only 30% more than Mercury)
BUDGET + SERVICE: AmeriFreight
- ✅ $0.87/mi (cheaper than Sherpa, more reliable than Mercury)
- ✅ Military discounts available
- ✅ 4.4/5 rating (good but not best)
❓ Frequently Asked Questions About Mercury Auto Transport (2026)
Q1: Is Mercury Auto Transport Legit?
Short Answer: Yes, legitimate. Licensed broker since 2007 (19+ years), A+ BBB rating, 4.6/5 Trustpilot. However, 10-15% of customers report delays, price increases, or communication issues. Real but mixed experiences.
Q2: Why Is Mercury Auto So Much Cheaper?
Short Answer: Mercury focuses on volume (4,000+ carriers in network) and lower margins. They broker between customers and carriers (don’t own trucks), which reduces overhead. Trade-off: less control over carrier quality, which is why some experiences are poor.
Q3: Will Mercury Increase My Price After I Book?
Short Answer: Possible but not guaranteed. 10-15% report quote increases after booking (especially if switching carriers). Mercury claims carrier miscommunication but still charges customer the difference. Sherpa locks pricing for 30 days (safer).
Q4: Does Mercury Auto Have GPS Tracking?
Short Answer: No. Mercury doesn’t offer real-time GPS tracking. You rely on driver/customer service updates (unreliable). Competitors Sherpa, Montway, and SGT offer live tracking.
Q5: What If My Pickup Is Delayed?
Short Answer: Mercury offers no compensation for delays. 10-15% report delayed pickups (3+ days). Communication during delays is poor – you must call them to get updates. Sherpa and Montway have better on-time records (<5-8% delays).
Q6: Is Mercury Auto Transport Better Than Sherpa?
Short Answer:
- Mercury wins on price: $0.72/mi vs Sherpa $0.96/mi (30% cheaper)
- Sherpa wins on reliability: 4.9/5 vs Mercury 4.6/5, <5% delays vs Mercury 10-15%
Choose Mercury: If budget is ONLY priority and you accept delays
Choose Sherpa: If you want peace of mind and reliable service
